Home›Blog›Safety Tips & FAQs

Safety Tips & FAQs

Social Security Disability Benefits

By Shiner Law Group · · 5 min read

Note on current Florida law: this article was published on January 8, 2019, before Florida’s 2023 tort reform law (HB 837) took effect on March 24, 2023. Some details may have changed — for example, most negligence injury claims must now be filed within two years instead of four. For advice on current law, call (561) 777-7700.
In This Article
  1. Mental or Physical Impairment
  2. Gainful Work
  3. Lasting Disability
  4. Disability Freeze
  5. How the Administration of Social Security decides that the Individual has a Disability?

Many illnesses and injuries are disabling; these include congestive heart failure, advanced cancers and kidney diseases. However, there are a few medical conditions that become critical with age or residual illnesses that become acute over time and eventually become disabling. For example, an employee may have suffered from a back injury years ago. But, he failed to recover from it and reached a point where the pain made it almost impossible for him to work. That person could be eligible for benefits of disability even though the injury or illness wasn’t disabling in the beginning.

Disability benefits to workers may be provided under Social Security disability. Since the government runs this program, it has several qualifying regulations and rules. To receive benefits under Social Security disability program, these three conditions need to be true:

  • The worker has a mental or physical impairment
  • The impairment prevents them from doing gainful work of any kind
  • The disability has lasted a minimum 12 months or is expected to last for the same amount of time or it is expected that the person will die from the disability

These terms may be interpreted differently by different people. The courts and Social Security has, therefore, developed guidelines regarding specific qualification for disability. Proving the disability is often extremely difficult. In preparing the disability claim, people should carefully examine the guidelines, discuss the case with a doctor and take help from an experienced attorney.

Social Security Disability Benefits

Mental or Physical Impairment

The general rule about disability is that if a condition that’s preventing an individual from working isn’t medically substantiated i.e. it cannot be discovered by doctors and described by them, then it isn’t considered a disability. In order for an individual to prove that they have a medical condition, when they file their disability claim, they should bring detailed records from the doctor and their statement; or from clinics and hospitals where they have been provided medical treatment. The records should describe the condition that is preventing them from working and also discuss how the limitations affect the individual. In addition, the records should state that the disability is likely going to last for a minimum of 12 months.

Gainful Work

When an individual applies for Social Security, the Social Security will consider whether their condition is preventing them from working in the same job that they had before they become disabled. If the disability is preventing them from performing their usual job, the next thing that’ll be decided by Social Security is that whether they can do any sort of gainful work. Gainful work is defined currently as any kind of job that gives a salary of USD 1,180 or more per month.

The education, work experience, training and age of the individual will be taken into consideration when determining this as well the practicality of acquiring/learning new skills required for another job. It’ll be evaluated by the Social Security whether the individual is capable of earning from any sort of work and whether there are any jobs for the individual where they live.

Lasting Disability

Even if the condition is serious or has completely disabled the individual, the individual won’t be eligible for Social Security disability benefits unless their condition has at least lasted for a period of 12 months or it is expected that the condition will last for the same time period. Benefits will also be provided if it’s expected that the condition will result in the death of the individual. Even though the requirement is 12 months, the individual doesn’t have to wait a year to apply.

If the medical condition is indeed disabling and the doctor has predicted that it’s going to last for a minimum 12 months, the individual may be eligible for Social Security disability. After the person has started receiving benefits and the disability of the individual doesn’t last for one year, Social Security can’t ask them to return the money. The individual won’t be penalized if they recover sooner than a year since the expectation was that the illness is going to last for a minimum 12 months. However, Social Security carries out continuing reviews of disability and may terminate the benefits of the individual later.

Disability Freeze

The average income of an individual over the working years is used to determine the total amount of their disability and retirement benefits. If, after the disability, the individual is earning a lot less than they were before, then those earning may pull their average income down resulting in less payments by Social Security. However, if the disability of a person led to them earning lower wages, then disability freeze may be put by the Social Security on their earnings record. Disability freeze allows an individual to continue working and collecting their lower income without it having an impact on their lifetime average income.

How the Administration of Social Security decides that the Individual has a Disability?

The process used by the administration of Social Security for deciding whether an individual is disabled and entitled to benefits is as follow:

1st Step: Is the Individual Working?

If a person is working and their earnings average over USD 1,180 a month, then they aren’t considered disabled.

2nd Step: Is the Individual’s Condition Severe?

The claim of an individual will be considered only if their condition is severe enough to interfere with their work related activities.

3rd Step: Is the Disability of the Individual Listed in Disabling Conditions?

A specific list of disabling medical conditions is maintained by Social Security. If the condition of an individual is listed there, it automatically means that they’re disabled. If not, the administration of the Social Security will decide if the condition of the individual is equal in severity to a condition in the list.

4th Step: Can the Individual Carry Out the Work They Did Previously?

If the condition of the individual isn’t equal in severity to any condition on Social Security’s list, then the administration can determine if their condition interferes with their ability to carry out the same work they did previously.

5th Step: Can the Individual Perform any Other Work?

If an individual cannot do the same work they did previously, the administration of Social Security will determine if they’re capable of doing a less mentally or/and physically demanding job.

Florida Personal Injury LawyerHow Shiner Law Group handles these cases across FloridaView Practice Guide
David I. Shiner, founding attorney of Shiner Law Group

About Shiner Law Group

David I. Shiner

Founding Attorney · Member, The Florida Bar

David Shiner has represented injury victims throughout Florida since 2002, and his firm has recovered more than $500 million for injured clients and their families. From seven offices across Florida, Shiner Law Group handles car, truck and motorcycle crashes, wrongful death, premises liability and other serious injury cases, every one on a no-fee-unless-we-win basis.

Meet David Shiner »

Related Articles

Safety Tips & FAQs

Boating Safety Tips for Memorial Day Weekend

Florida attorney David Shiner shares Memorial Day boating safety tips, life jacket laws, BUI penalties, and what to do if you're injured…

· 13 min read
Safety Tips & FAQs

Holiday Driving Safety Tips for South Florida

Stay safe on South Florida roads this holiday season. Essential driving tips, accident prevention strategies, and what to do if you're injured.…

· 8 min read

Have Questions About Your Case?

This article explains the law. An attorney can tell you what it means for you. Shiner Law Group has recovered more than $500 million for injured Floridians.

Call (561) 777-7700
  • Free, confidential consultation
  • No fee unless we win
  • Available 24/7
  • Se habla español

Free Case Review

Confidential · No obligation · Available 24/7

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice, nor does it create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change, and this article may not reflect the most current Florida law. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Attorneys at Shiner Law Group are Members of The Florida Bar. Attorney Advertising.