Contact Us Now: (800) 364-4444
Shiner Law Group Accident and Injury Lawyers
Free Consultation · Call 24/7
(800) 364-4444

What Makes A Personal Injury Lawyer The Best In Their City?

by Last updated Dec 11, 2023Personal Injury

If you were in a personal injury accident, you know how fragile life can be. Whether you experienced a motor vehicle crash or even a slip and fall, your whole life can change in the blink of an eye. These accidents not only leave you with debilitating injuries and excruciating pain but also with extensive medical bills that can forever impact your life and your family.

That is why having an experienced personal injury attorney on your side is crucial to the recovery of compensation and justice that you need in these times of crisis. If you need legal help but don’t know where to start, there are a few common areas that can help you review a law firm relatively quickly.

First and foremost, look for a law firm with years of experience handling all types of personal injury cases. A skilled legal team can help you through the challenging ordeal of a personal injury suit and assist you as you pursue the justice and financial recovery you deserve. However, before you choose just any attorney to take on your legal claim, you need to know what makes someone the best personal injury lawyer in your city.

Find a Lawyer Who Is Ready and Willing to Help You

Although all attorneys claim they can help you after an accident, not all of them are willing to put in the work. That is why when you look for the best personal injury attorney in your city, you want to find one who will answer all your questions and concerns, not one that makes you feel like you are bothering them when you contact them for an update on your case.

Your lawyer should be available when you need an update to know what is happening with your legal case at all times. Look for policies on the firm’s website and ask if your lawyer is willing to supply you with their cell phone number before you choose who will represent you.

The Best Lawyers Have the Experience to Take on the Most Difficult Cases

Another important quality of a successful personal injury lawyer is that they have the experience needed to take on the most challenging personal injury cases, including outside and within the courtroom. These attorneys know what it takes to maximize your chance of obtaining a successful outcome and are not afraid to pursue these options.

For these reasons, before hiring an attorney, you should ask:

  • How long has the attorney been in practice?
  • What percentage of the lawyer’s experience involves personal injury cases?
  • Does the lawyer have experience taking on the insurance company or going to trial?

The longer your lawyer’s résumé and the more successful cases they have to show for their years of experience, the better. However, probably most important that the firm’s successes line up with the type of case you have brought forth.

What Makes A Personal Injury Lawyer The Best In Their City

Review Your Lawyer’s Record of Success

It is common for lawyers to promise you that they will get you the results you want so that you choose them as your lawyer. However, unless they have a record of success in winning personal injury cases, you may be getting an attorney that does not have the experience or the resources to take on your specific case. You must look at the firm’s success rate to see what cases the attorney has taken on and their past outcomes.

Lawyers must fight hard for every last dollar you need. We recommend you review the case results of any legal firm you are considering to represent your case. Most firms will include their results directly on their website. If you can’t find the information you’re looking for to give you confidence, ask!

What to Expect From a Personal Injury Lawyer

To bring a successful personal injury claim, you need to provide reliable evidence and sound legal arguments proving your case. However, following a personal injury accident, this is likely the last thing on your mind. Thankfully, when you work with a skilled and experienced law firm, you will not have to take on this complex legal battle alone.

Once you retain an experienced personal injury attorney, you can expect them to:

  • Go over your accident, determine if you have a viable claim, and determine what legal options you can pursue.
  • Investigate your personal injury accident thoroughly and gather the evidence required to prove liability and damages, often with the help of industry experts.
  • Answer all of your questions and concerns, and provide you with the legal advice you need during this difficult time.
  • Handle all the negotiations with the other side and fight for a just settlement.
  • Take your case to trial if the other side will not negotiate and fight for the maximum compensation you deserve.

Essential Qualities of the Best and Most Reputable Personal Injury Attorney

Qualified personal injury attorneys possess several crucial traits. Consider the following when looking for a trustable lawyer to grant the best outcome from your compensation claim:


Among all the parties involved in your case, your attorney is your only friend to whom you can reach out for support and guidance, so it’s prudent to pick one who’s readily available. They should be within your current location, a place you can reach quickly when you need their services.

Reliable attorneys inform you how often you’re expected to hear from them and how they plan to maintain communication. They must also have a dedicated support team comprising knowledgeable representatives to answer any questions you may have for them.


Personal injury claims can get complex, especially if several parties could be at fault or the insurance company is uncooperative. It takes a seasoned attorney with several years under their belt to win. Experienced practitioners have handled numerous similar cases and have accumulated knowledge, expertise, and skills.

During their law school years, attorneys learn legal research skills, how to write legal options and the process of arguing complex concepts. But they need sufficient experience to handle other complexities like managing several cases, understanding customers’ needs, and working with other attorneys, court personnel, and judges.

Don’t fear if a young lawyer is your only option. Just ensure that they’re supported by a strong team of seasoned law professionals.


You must heed numerous legal considerations to win your injury claim, and there’s no room for mistakes. Therefore, only partner with an attorney who handles their practice with the utmost professionalism.

Besides always answering your questions and addressing every legal issue that comes up, the best personal injury lawyers also align their agencies with the best practices of their city or state bar association. They should be reputable for handling their customers with affection and care and must be passionate about achieving the best outcome from the negotiations, mitigation, or court proceedings.

Great Listener

Understanding the complex elements and coming up with a solid case takes a remarkable listener, but not every attorney can do it perfectly. For the sake of your case, avoid any attorney who does all the talking, interrupts you, and gives opinions even before you tell your story.

This attribute could carry over to the lawyer’s conversations with colleagues, witnesses, experts, and judges, and they might miss crucial information. Consequently, they might end up with an unfavorable outcome.

But if they observe keenly and listen intently without interrupting you, it’s a sign that they can analyze your claim comprehensively and create a strong case.

A Practical Problem Solver

You’re looking for an attorney to find legal remedies to your problem, so it only makes sense to partner with one who displays remarkable problem-solving skills. Personal injury claims aren’t as straightforward, and you must present sufficient evidence, determine fault, prove negligence, and collect adequate witness testimonies.

The best attorneys come equipped with problem-solving skills gained by reading case studies, attending trials, and evaluating real cases. Apart from being great at finding solutions, your attorney should also be flexible, open-minded, and dependable.

These skills will help them:

  • Answer your case’s big question
  • Identify loopholes in evidence and events
  • Determine your claim’s possible outcomes early
  • Be your ideal advocate, educating you about the claims process and remedies

Specialty in Your Personal Injury Claim

Nothing is stopping a child custody attorney from handling an injury claim, but you don’t want to involve someone who lacks expertise in your particular circumstances.

What’s more, personal injury law has various categories, including premises liability, auto accidents, product liability, medical malpractice, assault, toxic tort, nursing home abuse, dog bites, and many more. So it helps to choose one who specializes in your injury and is passionate about their specialty.

Brilliant Litigator and Mediator

Your avenues to legal remedies for your injury claim include litigation, mediation, and trial. Most cases settle before making it to trial because going to court can be lengthy, costly, and detrimental to both parties. The case’s outcome will depend on your attorney’s knowledge and experience in litigation and mediation.

While you may need reimbursement as soon as possible, you shouldn’t leave cash on the table by rushing to a settlement. A seasoned litigator and mediator will know when to fight or bend to maximize your claim recovery.

Thorough Investigator

You need sufficient facts to win your injury claim, so there’s a need for an independent, comprehensive investigation. The police report alone isn’t enough to build a case, determine fault, prove negligence, and recover damages. That’s why you must investigate the accident independently to gather and preserve critical evidence.

The attorney you choose should be a thorough investigator reputable for solving the most complex cases. They should also have a vast network of experts to aid their investigations, including medical practitioners, finance specialists, reconstructionists, and others.

This is what will help them prove fault and recover the maximum potential compensation within the four-year deadline highlighted in Florida Statutes section 95.11(3)(a).

A Track Record of Solid Settlements

Your legal representative should have a rich history of successful judgments and settlements for their clients. By checking out customer testimonials on the specific website, you’ll understand the experience to expect from the law firm.

A confident attorney with a remarkable history won’t hesitate to share their successes with you. But if they can’t, it’s a red flag that you’re working with the wrong lawyer and have to find a new person immediately.

Remarkable Online Reviews

Most customers first check out web reviews to size up a prospective company’s services, and you can do the same when weighing your options for personal injury attorneys.

You shouldn’t trust everything you read on the internet, but you can quickly tell an attorney’s reputation through reviews on the site and other independent comparison platforms. Be cautious of law firms with no reviews, only a handful, or negative remarks.

Searching for reviews and analyzing them isn’t as quick or straightforward. Still, you can narrow your options by only considering lawyers specializing in your particular type of injury claim.

Genuine Care and Compassion

Injuries are among the most devastating events to experience, and the accident could have left you with additional harms like mental anguish, emotional stress, and financial damages. If you’re not comfortable interacting with a personal injury attorney, they’re not the right one.

In this state, it would be in your best interests to partner with a genuinely compassionate lawyer who’s concerned about you and your loved ones.

Reputable attorneys understand the needs and struggles of customers and their family members. They’ll prioritize your well-being and fight for your rights to get you the deserved compensation.

Favorable Fee Schedule

Costly legal fees are among the key things that discourage personal injury plaintiffs from seeking legal services. As one would expect, the best lawyers in the industry charge exorbitantly, and most believe that it’s not possible to afford their representation. But this might not be the case.

Reputable law firms offer flexible fee schedules that befit every client. For instance, you shouldn’t pay for the first case evaluation. They won’t charge you upfront after confirming that you have a valid case. Instead, you’ll pay on a contingency-fee-basis. This means you won’t spend a dime on them unless you’ve won your claim, and they’ll deduct their pay from the settlement check.

Notably, some cunning lawyers advertise favorable fee schedules but charge clients for expenses even if they don’t win money. You don’t want this situation, so always consider an attorney transparent about their policies and fees.

Get The Best Outcome For Your Personal Injury Case

If, unfortunately, you or someone close gets injured in an accident and you’re confident it resulted from someone’s negligence, the law allows you to seek compensation from them. However, the claims process can be daunting, especially if the stakes are high and the incident’s aftermath is dire.

It’s hard to gather sufficient evidence and manage critical documentation after an accident. The responsible party might deny your claim or argue that you didn’t practice reasonable care, so you’re partly at fault. Finally, profit-minded insurance providers (including your own) may exploit you with low-ball settlement offers if you don’t know your legal rights.

You can avoid the hurdles and boost your chances of getting fair compensation by involving a personal injury attorney. Only the best, most qualified counselors guarantee the best outcome, but the trouble comes when you want to search for a practitioner you can count on.

Every personal injury lawyer out there claims to be the best in their city, and the numerous options available can make it even more complicated to make the right choice. Fortunately, you can get it right by verifying whether they satisfy several critical attributes of a successful personal injury attorney.

Speak With A Lawyer Today

If a personal injury accident disrupted your life, do not wait any longer to get the legal help you need. With these simple tips, you’ll be able to review your potential counsel and determine which legal firm is truly the best fit for your needs and your case. Once you have narrowed down your search, seek the assistance of a personal injury lawyer as soon as possible.

Schedule a Free Consultation